- What counts as receiving the property?
- Why do builder timelines create risk?
- Is a finished unit safer than one still being built?
- How do you identify a property that is not finished?
- Who should pay the builder's deposit?
- What protections should the contract have?
- Should you identify backup property?
- What if you want to build on your own terms?
- What does an illustrative timeline look like?
- What to keep in mind
Yes, as long as you actually close on it in time. A newly built home, condo or commercial building from a builder can be replacement property in a 1031 exchange, provided it is held for investment and you take title within 180 days of selling your relinquished property, or by your tax return due date if that comes first. The difficulty is not the tax rule. It is that builders run on construction schedules, and construction schedules slip while your exchange deadlines do not move.
This article is educational only. It is not tax, legal or investment advice. Your exchange agreement, your purchase contract and your own facts decide what happens, so review the plan with your CPA, a real estate attorney and your Qualified Intermediary.
What counts as receiving the property?
For a 1031 exchange, you receive replacement property when ownership transfers to you, which in practice means the deed is recorded at closing. Signing a builder's purchase agreement, paying a deposit or picking finishes does not count. If the builder has not delivered title by day 180, the property generally cannot complete your exchange, however close it is to being finished.
Why do builder timelines create risk?
A builder's contract usually gives an estimated completion date, not a promised one. Many form contracts allow the builder to push completion back for weather, labor, materials, permits, inspections and other causes, sometimes by many months, without being in breach. A certificate of occupancy may be needed before the lender will fund or the title company will close. Any one of those can move the closing date past your deadline.
That mismatch is the core issue. Your 45 day identification period and 180 day exchange period start the day your sale closes and run on calendar days. They do not extend for weekends, holidays or a builder's delay.
Is a finished unit safer than one still being built?
Generally, yes. A unit that is already complete, sometimes called inventory or a spec home, behaves much like any resale property. The main question is whether the builder can close within your window.
A unit that has not been started, or is in early framing, carries far more timing risk. If your sale is closing soon and the builder is quoting a completion date four or five months out, there is very little room for anything to go wrong. Pre construction condo projects that collect deposits and close a year or more later generally cannot fit inside a standard 180 day exchange at all.
How do you identify a property that is not finished?
You identify it in writing within 45 days, the same as any other replacement property. If you will close on a completed unit, a clear address or lot and unit description is usually enough. If you expect any part of the construction to still be underway when you take title, the regulations ask for a legal description of the land and as much detail about the planned improvements as is practicable at the time.
What you receive also has to be substantially the same as what you identified. If the builder substitutes a different lot or a materially different floor plan, that can create a problem. Your Qualified Intermediary can tell you how they prefer the identification to be written.
Who should pay the builder's deposit?
Builders often ask for a sizable deposit when the contract is signed, and sometimes more deposits for upgrades as construction moves along. How those are paid matters.
- ›If your sale has already closed, the cleaner route is usually to assign the purchase contract to your Qualified Intermediary and have the intermediary pay the deposit from your exchange funds. If the deal later falls through, any refunded deposit should go back to the intermediary, not to you.
- ›If you pay a deposit with your own money, it is generally credited to you at closing, which is fine, but you usually cannot simply reimburse yourself out of the exchange funds without creating taxable boot.
- ›Upgrade and option payments made outside closing are treated the same way. Extras paid through the closing statement can usually be covered by exchange funds.
Some builder contracts restrict assignment. Most intermediaries only need the builder to accept a notice of assignment, but check the contract before you sign it.
What protections should the contract have?
Because the builder controls the schedule, the contract is where you get some control back. Points owners often raise with their attorney include:
- ›An outside closing date that falls before your day 180, with a right to cancel and recover deposits if it is missed
- ›Limits on how far and for what reasons the builder can extend completion
- ›Permission to assign the contract to a Qualified Intermediary
- ›Clarity on what happens to deposits if the closing cannot happen in time
Builders do not always agree, but knowing which terms are fixed shows how much timing risk you are taking on.
Should you identify backup property?
Under the three property rule, you can identify up to three replacement properties of any value. Owners buying new construction commonly use one slot for the new build and one or two for properties that could close on a more predictable schedule, such as a resale property or, for accredited investors, a Delaware Statutory Trust interest. Backups are not a guarantee, but they give the exchange somewhere to go if the builder runs late.
DST interests are securities offered only to accredited investors through a licensed broker dealer and definitive offering documents. They carry risk, including the possible loss of principal, and are not suitable for everyone.
What if you want to build on your own terms?
If what you really want is to fund construction with exchange money, that is a different structure, usually called an improvement or build to suit exchange. It uses an exchange accommodation titleholder to hold title while improvements are made, and it has its own costs and rules. It deserves a separate conversation with your intermediary.
What does an illustrative timeline look like?
This is an illustrative example only, not a projection. An owner's rental sale closes on day 0. On day 10 they sign a contract for a builder's townhome, quoted for completion in about four months, and assign it to their intermediary, which pays the deposit. On day 40 they identify the townhome plus one resale property as a backup. If the builder delivers on day 130, there are roughly 50 days of cushion. If materials delays push completion to day 200, the townhome cannot complete the exchange, and the owner would need to close on the backup or accept that the exchange fails.
What to keep in mind
New construction can work well in a 1031 exchange when the property is close to finished and the contract gives you real protection on timing. The less complete the property, the more the exchange depends on a schedule you do not control. Before you sign with a builder, walk through the dates with your CPA, a real estate attorney and your Qualified Intermediary.
Ready to see real options?
Get illustrative DST, net-lease, and fund options matched to your situation — free, no obligation.
This article is educational and not tax, legal, or investment advice. 1031 exchanges are complex — consult your own CPA and attorney. DST and fund offerings are securities available to accredited investors only; all examples are illustrative.
